Nhibernate and the unit of work pattern dependency injection and unit of work using castle windsor and nhibernate since this issue is related to nhibernate, so, if you have any further questions about it, i suggest you could post your problem to nhibernate forum. Unit of work features is a poor repository implementation. How to implement the repository pattern in an asp net mvc. Net mvc, then i got feedback against the repositoryunit of work pattern. Repository and unit of work pattern programming with. You need to pick which one works best for your project specific needs. This can be achieved with implementing the repository pattern, the repository pattern is often implemented with the unit of work pattern. Note, for simplicity in the article, weve focused strictly on the nhibernate repository pattern, but weve left out an important logical piece of the repository pattern, which is the implementation of a business layer. I have a unit of work repository pattern in place to abstract away some nhibernate. Two primary implementations of the entity framework repository and unitofwork pattern provide a design for persisting entities within individual blocks of context or via a global context per web request. The repository pattern and unit of work pattern are used together most of the time. For uow, when dealing with aggregate roots the ar itself is a unit of work implementation. Correct use of repository and unit of work patterns in asp.
Im using nhibernate but i keep in mind to provide a layer of abstraction and to make it possible to switch to another data access provider entity framework for example. I could have finder methods that return iquerable that allows for method chaining etc. It seems like in a web app, because your unit of work may be split across multiple web requests and therefore sessions, its hard to use nhibernates change tracking etc effectively and i find myself doing unit of work tracking. Net mvc 5 or web api 2 application, i came up with this solution. What is that all about the repository anti pattern. The code above works well since the repository methods are a unit of work by default. The repository and unit of work patterns are intended to create an abstraction layer between the data access layer and the business logic layer of an application. Most of my storage operations follow the retrievemodifypersist pattern, so find, get, and save download complete source code introduction creating a generic repository pattern in an mvc3 application with entity framework is the last topic that we are about to cover in our journey of learning mvc.
This class is automatically added when you install the ninject. Net entity framework core generic async operations with. That is the job of the unitofworkapplication, which handles the session per request pattern. The 2nd part i know is trickly, and requires someone with solid nhibernate unit of work design pattern knowledge. Sign in sign up instantly share code, notes, and snippets. Most examples ive seen though use the pattern a little differently. Daniel, i am a big supporter of the repository pattern, however i am against the generic repository. Page 254 shows the implementation of the nhunitofwork which seems fine. A simple flatten will likely work or minor projection. Repositories on top unitofwork are not a good idea rob.
Implementing the repository and unit of work patterns in. An easy to use repository and unitofwork pattern for nhibernate. In a typical web application, you put the isession in asp. For a better understanding of the context class and dbset properties and how they work with ef core overall, you can read getting started with ef core article. In particular ill be utilizing the repository pattern and implement it with nhibernate as data access framework. Unit of work factory is used to initialize nhibernate active record and to create new units of work. One pattern that still seems particularly common among. There is more than one way to implement the unit of work and repository patterns. I am reading the official your first nhibernate based application while the tutorial is good and easy to follow, i am wondering why the repository pattern is used. In the various add, update, remove methods in the productrepository implementation, the code is nearly identical they are all using transactions, and the difference is in the meat i. There are many tutorials about the repository pattern and many of them are conflicting. Entity framework and nhibernate are objectrelational mapping frameworks.
Then it shows how this pattern can be used with ioc and unit test. Nhibernate and the unit of work pattern nhibernate. When trying to decide between using the entity framework and nhibernate as an orm, what are the advantages and disadvantages of entity framework and nhibernate. First of all fantastic book but im a bit confused about the use of the unit of work pattern and the implementation for nhibernate. Many unit of work and repository implementations over entity framework do not respect the interfaces of the patterns correctly, and therefore the abstractions do not serve any purpose.
Unit of work is the concept related to the effective implementation of the repository pattern. A dataaccessobject repository is also introduced that uses features from both styles of implementations and is also intended to work with query objects. In this webinar, microsoft mvp and infragistics evangelist dj kumar will cover the following topics. I began using this pattern with nhibernate around 2006 and only abandoned its use a few years ago. The author is trying to abstract away nhibernate and is being counseled rather heavily not to do so. After introducing a wellknown repository pattern into our application, you will learn to deal with legacy databases. In my opinion, the single reason for and goal of abstracting unit of work and repository again, on top of entity frameworks database context and its entity sets, would be. Note that if a unit of work method calls this removefriendship method, disabling this method is ignored, and it will use the same unit of work with the caller method.
I will use the repository pattern with unit of work to implement a data layer for my demo application. However we are in luck, modern orms like nhibernate and entity framework support implicit unit of work. Make sure to have the latest version of entityframework included in you project. Implementing these patterns can help insulate your application from changes in the data store and can facilitate automated unit testing or testdriven development tdd. When you save an ar, all changes are saved as one unit by the. Unit of work is referred to as a single transaction that involves multiple operations of insertupdatedelete and so on. In nhibernate the session object takes the role of the unit of work container.
The repository pattern creates an abstract layer between the data access layer and the service layer of an application. The article will focus on unit of work pattern and repository pattern, and shows how to perform crud operations in an mvc. I am using ef6 code first to create a database with 3 tables. To be more code complete here is a snippet of my nhibernate repository that returns the initial query. Implementing domain logic with urf service pattern. In the previous two chapters i introduced the unit of work pattern and developed a working version based on nhibernate. This article discusses the usage of repository pattern with unit of work. Are there alternatives to repository for data access. If repository pattern is overkill for modern orms ef. With the repository pattern, we create an abstraction layer between the data access and the business logic layer of an application. Ditch the repository pattern already 20 february, 2018. Im fairly new to programming still and in a class i took, we used quite a bit of repository pattern and i got experience using ado. Entity framework already implements the unit of work pattern with the dbcontext, however you should always work an abstraction of this, you can read up on one of previous post. Sounds like a lot of work, managing object state, relationships, concurrency and transactions can be cumbersome.
In particular, in the constructor for unitofwork, most examples start the transaction immediately and have. In my recent post, i explained how to implement a decoupled, unittestable, n tier architecture based on generic repository pattern with entity framework, ioc container and dependency injection in asp. Repositories on top unitofwork are not a good idea. I want to build upon what i have already learned by implementing the unit of work pattern along with repository pattern using ado. About nhibernate or any orm, i think they are an implementation detail of a repository. Another post request from the forum oren, id love to get some detail on how to make the most of nhibernates unit of work capability in a web app scenario. One weak point of the shown implementation is that it is strictly non thread safe. Implementing the repository and finder patterns russell. Repository with unit of work, ioc and unit test codeproject. The repository mediates between the domain and data mapping layers, acting like an inmemory collection of domain objects. Plus i have not allowed for and, or or not as that is a different topic. This will be followed by retrieving data from database. In the agathas case study, why do you insist on providing a unitofwork interface and a nhunitofwork implementation class. Next, you will optimize your code, explore concepts such as the onion architecture, and learn where nhibernate fits best in an applications architecture.
Therefore i will combine them in this post and show how to implement them both. It allows you to completely separate working with entity classes from the actual data access code. You do not use it, after all i think, it was a copy and paste from chapter 7, where you presented a sample uow implementation using dictionaries. Framework now ships returning all things tentity or ienumberable for compartmentalization, you will need to change the repository. In this article you will learn how to use the repository pattern for crud operations and how to combine it with the unit of work patterns.
This template is designed for generating code implementing repositories and unit of work patterns for nhibernate model. In the comments there are a couple of blog entries by ayende on this topic. Implementing and using repositories with nhibernate. In this post, we will explore the repository and unit of work pattern, beyond using it to provide an abstraction over the entity framework, in order to gain a better understanding of the two patterns and well explore how to use the patterns in order to provide a data layer abstraction in software applications. All methods that are exposed from repository in service are overridable to add any pre or post domainbusiness logic.
This article is not about how to plumb a dependency injection di container in asp. If repository pattern is overkill for modern orms ef, nhibernate, what is a better abstraction. The repository pattern accordingly to martin fowler. If youve been confused about the proper way to implement the repository and unit of work patterns with. Its generally believed that by using the repository pattern, you can in summary decouple your data access from your domain and expose the data in a consistent way. The key pieces in this sample are demonstrations of the correct unitofwork pattern, using the nhibernate isession based object with its transaction support. Implementing repository and unit of work patterns with asp. On the next page there is an nhibernate base repository created which is passed an iunitofwork.
56 246 895 622 26 602 1287 344 1268 1195 38 334 987 1354 314 1356 401 593 395 467 658 397 1268 1343 1527 846 223 972 588 676 481 1043 293 702